DRULES AI
๐Ÿ  Home ๐Ÿ“ฐ Blog
โ† All posts

Suno Lawsuit: Court OKs Ex-Menlo Exec Deposition

On October 27, a federal magistrate judge in Massachusetts granted Universal Music Group and Sony Music the right to depose a former principal at Menlo Ventures regarding her deleted social media post about shifting most of her music listening to Suno.

๐Ÿ” Why target an investor's listening habits?

The post, first flagged months earlier by Music Business Worldwide, is being examined as potential evidence that AI-generated music substitutes for human recordings. Labels argue this demonstrates market harm, one of the four fair use factors central to Suno's defense. The deposition will allow lawyers to question the executive directly about the comment and any knowledge of Suno's operations.

โš–๏ธ How does this ruling advance the case?

This is a concrete procedural win for the labels in their ongoing litigation over training data and the v6 models. It follows Suno's recent answer admitting it has not deleted all prior training recordings. Subpoenas are now running both ways, with Suno issuing its own deposition subpoena to Apple. Updates as recent as October 28 indicate additional Suno investors are being pulled into the discovery process.

๐Ÿ“ˆ What are the broader industry implications?

These developments highlight how courts are increasingly scrutinizing user and investor behavior to assess economic impact. For the AI music ecosystem, every new ruling adds pressure toward licensing deals rather than prolonged litigation. Platforms continue operating, with Suno v6 trained on licensed major label content from partners like Warner, BMG, and Believe still available to creators.

๐ŸŽ›๏ธ What this means for your next song

Legal noise shouldn't halt creativity. Focus on Suno v6's licensed models to generate commercially viable output while the case unfolds. Start your workflow by feeding a strong concept into /genie to instantly receive a named record, full style prompt, voice description, chord progression, and structure. Refine the output with precise prompts that emphasize originality, then export stems for polishing in your DAW. Test variations quickly, track what resonates with listeners, and build a catalog that stands apart from generic generations. This disciplined approach turns legal uncertainty into motivation to create distinctive, high-quality tracks today.

Bottom line: The new deposition order sharpens focus on market substitution but leaves Suno v6 fully functional for creators ready to make their next original song.

Sources
๐ŸงžWrite your next song with the Song Genie
Name a record, say what it's about, and get the whole kit: style, voice, structure, chords and mastering. Three wishes free.